The Benefits & Challenges of Online Writing Communities

Former literary agent, now a freelance editor, writing teacher, and IP/story developer for major publishers and creators.

By Mary Kole

Creative writing is an art that requires continuous learning and improvement. The process of writing can be an isolating one, but it's vital to receive feedback from peers to assess your progress and identify your strengths and weaknesses. Getting constructive criticism from online writing communities is an effective way to improve your writing skills and finesse your craft. In this article, I’ll discuss the benefits of accessing these online writing communities and how they can assist you in your journey towards traditional publication or self-publishing.

Constructive Feedback and Skill Sharing in Online Writing Communities

Most writers are not born with a mastery of their craft, even if they have the desire to go on a creative writing journey. Gaining those skills takes time, effort, and guidance from experts in the field. Online writing communities can provide you with constructive feedback on your writing that can help refine your skills. Members of these online writing communities are often writers with very different but valuable perspectives, giving you the opportunity to learn new ways to approach your writing.

A writing group is also a supportive environment, which can help you build your confidence and encourage your voice. The exposure to different writing styles can contribute to a writer's growth, and the act of assessing other writers' work helps develop critical thinking skills.

Online Writing Communities Provide the Opportunity to Network

The writing world is vast, and networking is a crucial aspect of getting published, whether you’re aiming for traditional publication or self-publishing. By getting involved in online writing communities, you can gain valuable connections and exposure. You can meet critique partners and even potentially interface with publishing gatekeepers who can take your submission when you’re ready.

Engagement with other writers is a massive benefit of online writing communities, as your peers can help provide information and guidance on industry standards. Online writing communities can add rocket boosters to your creative journey. You'll also learn more about the process of publishing, as well as essential highlights on the various resources, tools, and resources that could help your writing career.

The Challenges of Online Writing Communities

Knowing where to find supportive online writing communities can be a struggle. However, you can learn about online writing communities from classes, podcasts, forums, Facebook groups, professional organizations, and workshops. Unfortunately, there are some downsides: You may encounter unconstructive, overly critical feedback or negative criticism that does not align with your voice or aesthetic as a writer.

Also, there's no guarantee of feedback quality across online writing communities. The truth is, some are built more effectively and run more professionally than others. Sometimes, it can be challenging to parse useful feedback from the vast number of critiques and opinions available. Moreover, the emotional toll of receiving a lot of writing notes rejection can affect your confidence in your abilities and the writing itself.

Are Online Writing Communities for You?

While online writing communities can contribute positively to your writing journey, it's essential to pause and evaluate whether you're ready to engage with one. Being part of a writing group or working with a critique partner, freelance editor, or beta reader requires a certain level of maturity and open-mindedness to constructive criticism, which challenges you to push beyond your comfort zone. You have to be ready for the challenge, or you won’t get the benefit of the experience.

To get the most out of critique, you should be willing to take feedback and writing notes without being defensive or dismissive. As much as possible, aim to understand the feedback and supplement your writing. The goal should be a transformational revision, learning, and growth. Working with online writing communities is about more than just perfecting your writing—it's about sharpening your eye, honing your craft, developing yourself as a writer, and persevering despite setbacks.

Working with online writing communities can be a rewarding and fulfilling experience, offering support and valuable feedback to help you improve your craft. Diving into the online writing communities comes with its challenges, such as criticism and a potential hit to your confidence. However, with the proper mindset and dedication, joining online writing communities can help you hone your skills, share feedback and knowledge, and propel your writing journey forward.

Want writing guidance, feedback, and accountability?

Self-guided writing study is great, but can only take you so far. Apply to Story Mastermind—a small group workshop intensive for your novel, memoir, outline, or picture book idea. Achieve a robust outline or draft, or a portfolio of picture books, in a rigorous but supportive environment. Imagine how much closer you can be to your writing goals after participating in Story Mastermind.