Benefits and Challenges of Working with A Critique Partner
Former literary agent, now a freelance editor, writing teacher, and IP/story developer for major publishers and creators.
By Mary Kole
While the act of creative writing happens in isolation, you don’t have to do everything alone. One of the best ways to improve your writing is to get feedback from a critique partner, beta reader, or freelance editor—someone who can read your work with fresh eyes, offer constructive criticism, and help you take your writing to the next level. Here, I’ll explore the benefits of working with a critique partner, as well as some of the challenges of this kind of collaboration.
The Benefits of Working with a Writing Critique Partner
Working with a creative writing critique partner is a great way to get objective feedback on your work. When you're writing, it's easy to get attached to your words and lose sight of the bigger picture. A critique partner can help you see things that you might have missed, point out opportunities for growth, and offer suggestions for how to improve your work.
Working with a critique partner can help you build your skills as a writer. When you're critiquing someone else's work, you're forced to think critically about what makes good writing and storytelling, and to make actionable suggestions for how to achieve it. You'll also have the opportunity to practice giving feedback in a constructive and helpful way, which is a valuable skill for any writer. Eventually, the insights you glean will help you self-edit and revise your own work.
The Challenges of Working with a Writing Critique Partner
Of course, working with a creative writing critique partner is not without its challenges. Perhaps the biggest one is finding the right match. You need to find someone who shares your vision for your work, has a similar level of experience and skill, and is willing to give and receive feedback in a respectful and constructive way. This can take time and effort, but it's worth it in the long run. You can check out Facebook groups specific to your genre or target audience, attend writing conferences, or check in with your local independent bookstore, library, or university to find writing classes and workshops.
Another challenge of working with a critique partner is that you’ll get feedback and criticism. While this is exactly the point, it can still feel scary or vulnerable to get writing notes. You’ll then be challenged to revise your work based on the feedback you receive. This requires a certain level of maturity as a writer, as well as a willingness to accept that you still have room to grow and learn. Working with a critique partner can be humbling, but it can also be incredibly rewarding if you're willing to make the most of the partnership and give as much as you get. Of course, some writers prefer to work alone, while others may not be ready for the rigors of collaboration and critique. That said, for those who are willing to take on the challenge, working with a critique partner can be incredibly valuable, both as a way to build skills and as a way to connect with others on the same writing journey.
Working with a creative writing critique partner can be a powerful tool for aspiring writers who want to improve their craft. Whether you're pursuing traditional publication or self-publishing, a critique partner can offer objective feedback, help you build skills, and challenge you to become a better writer. However, working with a critique partner is not without its challenges, and not everyone may be ready for this kind of collaboration. That said, if you're willing to put in the work, search for the right match, and make the most of the feedback you’ll get, working with a critique partner can be an incredibly rewarding experience that’s part of the process for most successful authors.
Want writing guidance, feedback, and accountability?
Self-guided writing study is great, but can only take you so far. Apply to Story Mastermind—a small group workshop intensive for your novel, memoir, outline, or picture book idea. Achieve a robust outline or draft, or a portfolio of picture books, in a rigorous but supportive environment. Imagine how much closer you can be to your writing goals after participating in Story Mastermind.