The Benefits and Challenges of Writing Critique Groups
Former literary agent, now a freelance editor, writing teacher, and IP/story developer for major publishers and creators.
By Mary Kole
Writing can be a solitary pursuit, but many successful authors find themselves creating communities for support. One of the best ways to improve your writing skills, as well as gain valuable feedback and constructive criticism, is to join creative writing critique groups or attend a writing workshop. Not only does networking with other creative writers give you the opportunity to share your work, it also lets you practice your critique skills on other manuscripts. But before you jump in headfirst, it's important to understand the benefits and challenges of joining creative writing critique groups, and how you might make the most of this time and emotional investment.
The Benefits of Joining Creative Writing Critique Groups
Joining creative writing critique groups can help you develop your writing craft. You can learn new techniques and styles of writing, as well as get feedback on your work from other writers who may have different perspectives and insights. You might also find critique groups with published authors in them, which can give you valuable information about taking your career to the next level.
You can also build relationships with other writers who are on a similar journey, or writing in a similar genre or for the same target audience. The relationships you make from joining critique groups can lead to valuable connections and collaborations in the future, and will also provide you with a support network for overcoming writer's block or hitting an obstacle in the submission or publishing process.
Most importantly, participating in creative writing critique groups allows you to cultivate your own critique skills, which are essential for any writer to have. You not only learn how to give feedback constructively, but you also learn how to receive feedback and incorporate it into your writing. When you offer writing notes on someone else’s manuscript, you’ll be internalizing the writing craft and gaining insights for your own self-editing and revision purposes.
The Challenges of Joining Creative Writing Critique Groups
While joining a critique group or writing workshop can be a transformative experience, it's not for everyone. You need to be mature enough in your craft to handle rigorous feedback from your future writing partners. Some writers may not be ready to have their work critiqued, or they may struggle to incorporate feedback into their writing while revising.
Critique groups and workshops can sometimes be competitive or have a negative atmosphere. Writers may feel intimidated or less confident in their skills if others in the group seem to be more advanced or don’t take the right approach to providing constructive criticism. It's important to be aware of this and find a group that is supportive and where everyone comes together with a common goal in mind.
One of the most significant challenges of searching for critique groups and writing workshops is finding the right one. Research your options online and in person. Many organizations offer writing courses or meetings specifically for writers who need critique partners. Online options abound, and you can find critique groups for any genre or target audience on Facebook and in dedicated venues like Shut Up and Write, Women’s Fiction Writers, and Creative Caffeine. However, before committing to a group, take care to observe its inner workings, try it out, and make a decision that’ll serve you in the future.
Some groups require a fee, but attending a meeting beforehand and checking out their process can give you some insight. If possible, ask for testimonials or talk to other writers about their experiences with the group or workshop.
Getting the Most Out of Creative Writing Critique Groups
To truly benefit from creative writing critique groups, you should participate actively and regularly, and commit to giving as much (or more) as you get. Make sure to show up prepared, ready to give and accept feedback. Take notes on any writing notes you receive, and try not to take what others say too personally. It's crucial to approach the critique process with an open mind and a willingness to grow as a writer. Use the feedback you receive to revise your work, and apply what you've learned to future projects. Offer your own feedback generously and watch the insights you’re gleaning filter back to your own work.
Joining creative writing critique groups can be a valuable experience for any aspiring writer. Still, it's important to understand the benefits and challenges, find the right group, and approach the critique process with an open mind and willingness to grow. With the right attitude and community, you can elevate your writing skills, make valuable connections, and level up in your publishing or self-publishing endeavors.
Want writing guidance, feedback, and accountability?
Self-guided writing study is great, but can only take you so far. Apply to Story Mastermind—a small group workshop intensive for your novel, memoir, outline, or picture book idea. Achieve a robust outline or draft, or a portfolio of picture books, in a rigorous but supportive environment. Imagine how much closer you can be to your writing goals after participating in Story Mastermind.